Is Your AI Health App Actually Protecting Your Data? The HIPAA Gap You Need to Know
The era of getting health advice from your smartphone, anytime, anywhere, has arrived. From OpenAI’s ChatGPT Health and Anthropic’s Claude for Healthcare to Google’s AI-powered health services, Big Tech is racing to dominate the medical space.
According to OpenAI, hundreds of millions of people already use ChatGPT for health and wellness questions. Moreover, multiple studies show that large language models (LLMs) can perform remarkably well in medical diagnosis tasks. But as AI health apps attract more users, concerns about the safety are growing just as fast.
The HIPAA Blind Spot: Where AI Health Apps Fall Through the Cracks
What is HIPAA?
In 1996, the United States enacted the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA). It requires covered entities to encrypt patients’ personal health information and mandates immediate notification to affected individuals and the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) in the event of a data breach. Its core purpose is to protect the privacy of medical records and ensure the security of health information.
HIPAA applies to healthcare providers such as doctors, nurses, and hospitals, as well as insurers and other organizations that process health-related data. The critical problem is that tech companies like OpenAI, Anthropic, and Google are very likely not subject to HIPAA obligations.
Andrew Crawford of the Center for Democracy and Technology has warned that countless companies outside HIPAA’s scope will be collecting, sharing, and monetizing people’s health data with little accountability.
Reading the fine print matters.
Anthropic’s website describes Claude for Healthcare as “built on HIPAA-ready infrastructure,” while OpenAI states that its healthcare enterprise products “support HIPAA compliance.” These phrases sound reassuring, but they are not the same as being legally bound by HIPAA.
Sara Geoghegan of the Electronic Privacy Information Center (EPIC) stated that because these AI companies are not actual HIPAA-covered entities, they may have no legal obligation to comply with HIPAA at all.
The Structural Security Risks Built Into AI Health Apps
Beyond the legal gap, AI health apps carry several inherent technical vulnerabilities.
Like all generative AI systems, these apps are exposed to risks including data breaches, hallucinations, and prompt injection attacks. In a healthcare context, any one of these failures can go beyond a simple information leak. It can translate directly into real-world health harm.
Data breach problems in the healthcare industry predate the AI boom. Healthcare organizations have long been prime targets for hacking, phishing, and ransomware attacks. Even HIPAA-covered institutions often fail to prevent breaches. Main reasons behind this is due to reliance on legacy software, complex third-party vendor networks, and the high cost of cybersecurity infrastructure. Making matters worse, AI tools sometimes operate in ways that even their own developers cannot fully explain or predict. This opacity poses serious security and privacy risks when the data being processed is as sensitive as personal health information.
What AI Health App Users Can Do Right Now
Until stronger legal regulations are established for AI health apps, it is important to know how to protect yourself at an individual level.
- Always read the Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
Even if a product claims to be “HIPAA-compliant,” that language may not carry actual legal weight. Check carefully whether the service sells or shares your data with third parties. - Minimize what sensitive information you share.
Avoid entering critical personal details such as your full name, Social Security number, or detailed medical history whenever possible. - Do not blindly trust AI diagnoses.
Treat AI responses as reference material only. For any important health decisions, always consult a qualified medical professional. - Make use of data deletion features.
Most services offer the ability to delete conversation history. Make it a habit to clear your data regularly.
The Age of AI Demands a Trusted Security Partner
As AI rapidly expands into healthcare, the role of proven security technology has never been more critical. If you are unwilling to give up the convenience AI offers, then at a minimum, your data must be backed by a verified, reliable security solution.
Penta Security has been a trusted security partner since 1997, building deep expertise in web application security and data encryption. In a world where technology consistently outpaces regulation, the most important safeguard is a trustworthy security infrastructure, one that works for the user, not against them. Using AI wisely while protecting data rigorously is the defining challenge of our time.
Click here to subscribe our Newsletter
